Few things generate more anxiety in home education than an unclear or overreaching request from a Local Authority. Some of what gets asked for is entirely reasonable. Some of it isn't, and knowing the difference is the single most useful piece of knowledge you can have as a home educating parent. This is the definitive, plain-English reference for exactly where that line sits, and why.
The One Distinction That Resolves Most Confusion
Before anything else, it's worth understanding that a Local Authority has two very different levels of power, and the boundaries below apply differently depending on which one you're dealing with.
An informal enquiry is a routine, ordinary check-in, typically an annual letter or email asking how home education is going and whether you'd like to update them on your child's progress. This carries no legal force, and responding to it, while sensible and reasonable, is not compelled by law in the same way a formal notice is.
A formal Section 437(1) notice is a specific legal document, served only where a Local Authority has formed the view that your child may not be receiving a suitable education. It requires you to satisfy the Local Authority, within a specified period of at least 15 days, that education is suitable. This is a genuinely different situation from a routine enquiry, and it's covered in full in our separate guide to School Attendance Orders.
Most of the requests home educating families find intrusive or confusing arrive framed as informal enquiries, but with a tone or level of detail that would only be appropriate for a formal notice. Recognising which one you're actually dealing with is most of the battle.
Informal Enquiry vs Formal Notice
What a Local Authority Can Reasonably Ask For
- Written information describing your educational approach. A brief, honest account of how your child is learning, covering literacy, numeracy, and the general shape of their education, is a reasonable and proportionate response to most enquiries.
- Confirmation of who has parental responsibility and that home education is genuinely taking place.
- Real examples of what your child has actually been learning, rather than only future plans or intentions. This does not need to mean handing over original work; a description of activities and progress is generally sufficient.
- An explanation of how the education suits your child's individual needs, including any additional needs, aptitudes, or circumstances relevant to what "suitable" means for that particular child.
- Annual contact, roughly once a year, to check in on how things are progressing. This is the frequency generally considered reasonable for an informal enquiry.
What a Local Authority Cannot Demand
- Entry to your home. A Local Authority officer does not have an automatic right to enter your home, and you are entitled to offer evidence in another form, such as in writing or at a neutral location, instead.
- To see or speak with your child alone. There is no general power in home education law that allows an officer to insist on interviewing your child without a parent present, as part of routine contact.
- A specific curriculum or timetable. You are not required to follow the National Curriculum, use any particular scheme of work, or structure your day like a school timetable.
- Copies of your child's actual work. There is no general statutory requirement in England to hand over original work samples, though you may choose to share some if it helps demonstrate suitability.
- Medical records or sensitive diagnostic detail beyond what is genuinely relevant to describing your child's educational needs.
- The names of other home educating families you may know or be connected with.
- Photos, video footage, or lesson plans as a matter of routine. These are not legal requirements for demonstrating suitable education.
- Long, generic forms unrelated to education. You are not obliged to complete extensive paperwork that strays well beyond the question of whether your child is receiving a suitable education.
Recognising which one you're actually dealing with, an informal enquiry or a formal notice, is most of the battle. The powers, and the boundaries, are genuinely different for each.
Can Ask / Cannot Ask
Why This Distinction Exists
The legal basis for all of this sits in Section 7 of the Education Act 1996, which sets the duty on parents to ensure their child receives an efficient, suitable, full-time education, and Section 437, which sets out what a Local Authority can formally do if it isn't satisfied that duty is being met. Nothing in either section gives a Local Authority a general right of entry, inspection, or interrogation. Its powers are specifically about being satisfied that suitable education is happening, not about dictating how it happens.
This matters because a great deal of what gets asked of home educating families in practice goes beyond what the law actually provides for, often not out of bad faith, but because individual officers or standard council forms haven't been updated to reflect this boundary clearly. Knowing where the line sits means you can respond confidently and proportionately, rather than either over-complying out of anxiety or under-responding out of frustration.
What to Do if a Request Feels Like Overreach
If you receive a request that goes beyond what's outlined above, you're entitled to politely decline the specific part that oversteps, while still offering a reasonable, proportionate response to the genuine underlying question of whether your child is receiving a suitable education. A short written response describing your approach and your child's progress is usually the most effective way to resolve an enquiry, whatever form the original request took.
If a request has escalated to a formal Section 437 notice, different rules and stricter timelines apply, and our full guide to School Attendance Orders covers that process end to end.
Download the free reference card
A single-page, two-column card setting out what a Local Authority can reasonably ask for, and what it cannot demand. Print it and keep it for the next time a letter arrives. Free, no signup needed.
Download the reference card (PDF)Frequently Asked Questions
Can a Local Authority officer just turn up at my door?
An officer does not have an automatic right of entry to your home, and an unannounced visit is not something you are obliged to accommodate. You can offer to respond in writing instead.
Do I have to let my child be interviewed alone?
No. There is no general power in home education law allowing this as part of routine contact. You're entitled to be present for any conversation involving your child.
Do I need to follow the National Curriculum to satisfy a Local Authority?
No. You are free to choose your own educational approach, provided it's suitable for your child's age, ability, aptitude, and any additional needs.
How often can a Local Authority contact me?
Annual contact is generally considered reasonable for an informal enquiry. Requests significantly more frequent than this, without a specific and stated concern, go beyond what's typically considered proportionate.
What's the difference between an informal enquiry and a formal notice?
An informal enquiry is a routine check-in with no legal compulsion attached. A formal Section 437(1) notice is a specific legal step, triggered by an actual concern, that requires a response within a set legal timeframe.
Can I just ignore a request I think is unreasonable?
It's generally better to respond, even briefly, addressing the genuine underlying question of suitability, rather than not responding at all. You can decline a specific overreaching element while still engaging constructively with the core enquiry.
Summary: The Boundary Line at a Glance
| A Local Authority CAN ask for | A Local Authority CANNOT demand |
|---|---|
| A written description of your educational approach | Entry to your home |
| Confirmation of parental responsibility | To interview your child alone |
| Real examples of learning that has taken place | A specific curriculum or timetable |
| An explanation of how education suits your child | Copies of original work |
| Roughly annual contact | Medical records or sensitive diagnostic detail |
| Names of other home educating families | |
| Photos, video, or lesson plans as routine | |
| Long forms unrelated to education |
Understanding this boundary doesn't make the relationship with your Local Authority adversarial. If anything, it makes it easier: a clear, confident, proportionate response is almost always more effective, for everyone, than either anxious over-compliance or defensive silence.
Little Folio is a record-keeping app built for home educating families in England. Log activities, store evidence, manage Local Authority correspondence, and generate professional reports in one place.
Last updated: September 2026. This post is for information only and does not constitute legal advice. Verify against current official guidance and seek independent legal advice for your specific circumstances.